Furry Brown Dog

Dedicated to the memory of my canine friend…

MM Lee acknowledges Singapore’s hotel-like growth model

with one comment

This was published on 21st Mar 2009.  I’ll reproduce it below in full in case the state media decides to take down the page:

MM Lee on Singapore’s population
By Leong Wee Keat and Lin Yanqin, TODAY | Posted: 21 March 2009 0949 hrs

SINGAPORE: Even after the millions spent on Baby Bonuses and other parenthood incentives, policy-makers are confounded by a problem that goes to the very heart of survival: Singaporeans are still not reproducing themselves.TODAY

And on Friday, Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew reflected on this challenge at the National University of Singapore Society’s (NUSS) dialogue on “Singapore and Singaporeans: A Quarter Century From Now”.

In Singapore, he said, it is becoming a “lifestyle choice” for women past the age of 30 to stay single as they are well-travelled and have no one to worry about.

“My daughter is one of them. What can I do? When she was in her early 30s, my wife used to tell her, what you want is a ‘MRS’. She did not think it was funny.

“Now she is 50-plus, her mother is bedridden, I’m on a pacemaker, I got this rambling house. Everything is looked after now. What happens if we are both not there?…

“She says, ‘I’ll look after myself’. But we know she has not been looking after herself all these years. When she went to Boston for training, her cooking was to just to put her salmon into the microwave.”

Mr Lee added: “But that’s life. It’s a choice that she has made, and a choice that 30 per cent of our women are making. Who am I to complain? Society lives with the consequences it is making.”

The problem that this trend creates: “Without new citizens and permanent residents, we are going to be the last of the Mohicans. We are going to disappear”.

But immigrants bring their own challenges to a society.

Some Singaporean parents have complained about migrants entering schools and competing with local children. He urged parents: “Would you want them to compete against you or with you as part of the team? If you don’t have them with you as part of your team, they will be on the Chinese and Indian team.”

Some of these migrant students, he acknowledged, use Singapore as a stepping stone to other countries. So “why are we so stupid” in allowing this?

“Because more than half (of these students) do not make the grade to go to America, and the second tier is not bad for us.”

Singapore needs to draw from a big talent pool beyond its own shores, “so that we can continue to punch above our weight. No other way”.

“Would you want the pie to grow? You want a small pie with your children taking the last portion, or a big pie where you get a bigger portion, even though the talented person may get a bigger slice? That’s life. If you are afraid of talent, you will not succeed.”

One catch he foresees: Even as the second generation of today’s immigrants become more Singaporean, one dubious habit they might also adopt, is to have only one child.

“So we got to make this breakthrough, otherwise we are going to have a constant problem.

“We got to get people to realise that if we don’t have 2.1 (babies) to replace ourselves, we are always dependent.”

Earlier in the evening, Mr Lee officially opened the new NUS Alumni Complex, which comprises the redeveloped NUSS Kent Ridge Guild House and Shaw Foundation Alumni House.

These few lines are shocking in particular:

Some Singaporean parents have complained about migrants entering schools and competing with local children. He urged parents: “Would you want them to compete against you or with you as part of the team? If you don’t have them with you as part of your team, they will be on the Chinese and Indian team.”

Some of these migrant students, he acknowledged, use Singapore as a stepping stone to other countries. So “why are we so stupid” in allowing this?

“Because more than half (of these students) do not make the grade to go to America, and the second tier is not bad for us.”

Much has been said about Singapore’s economic growth model being nothing more than a hotel.  I commented on something along those lines earlier.  The country had its origins dabbling in entrepot trade during Sir Stamford Raffles’ time. Fast forward over 150 years later, Singapore is still behaving like a hotel.  The country relies too much on foreign MNCs, foreign markets for exports and increasingly as can be seen above, foreign immigrants for labour and growth.  MM Lee has explicitly acknowledged above that he would rather take the “second tier” of rejected foreign student applicants and groom them in Singapore at the expense of Singaporean students. It’s clearly a zero-sum game; for every foreign applicant which applies successfully, one more Singaporean student gets crowded out.  

To make things worse, it’s not exactly the case that most foreign teaching assistants are well-versed in our working language, English.  To be taught by tutors with whom communication may be difficult is  a hellish torture; one has to explain multiple times to be understood and has to request the tutor to repeat himself/herself multiple times likewise to understand him/her.  Furthermore, NUS was recently reported to be in the top ten most expensive colleges in the world and possibly the most expensive in Asia.  What exactly are local students paying for?  On top of that, questions should also be asked to how much taxpayers’ money is used to subsidise foreign students’ tuition fees at NUS at the expense of crowding out local students.

Singapore needs to rethink it’s policies.  Seriously.

Written by defennder

April 1, 2009 at 11:46 PM

Posted in Singapore affairs

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. This blog’s great!! Thanks🙂.

    matt

    April 2, 2009 at 9:37 AM


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: